Three Chic Geeks

For the nerdy and proud. Warning: spontaneous geekgasms may occur.

The Fandom Wars: Round 4 (Semifinals)


The Fandom Wars - Semi Finals

Oh hey look so Satan Loki Freak Geek made a poll. And it’s nearly over. And if you’ve been keeping up with it, now is the time for the semi-finals, and there will be no joy or happiness or anything here for you. There will be no comfort for you. Only death. So, let’s go and vote!

fandomwars-round1Last turn ended with Buffyverse being eliminated hard by BBC Sherlock, possibly because Sherlock’s decided to out-sulk Angel and whatever Sherlock sets his mind to, he does. Harry Potter knocked Game of Thrones out of the running, proving that J.K. Rowling is the master of WHY DID YOU KILL THEM WHY.  Merlin lost to Supernatural on the magic and homosexuality front, and Star Trek was decimated by a wibbly-wobbly time lord opponent (Doctor Who).

The polls will close in exactly 72 hours! (more or less, depending on whether we remember how days of the week work following GISHWHES). Vote for your fandoms, but you can only vote once! This is to prevent cheating. If you try to cheat in favor of your team, WE WILL NOTICE AND WE WILL NOT BE OKAY WITH THAT. Want your fandom to win? Get all your friends to vote! Don’t ruin everyone’s fun please!

Now… it’s time to determine which fandoms are going ahead to the fourth round… If you need to read up on the fandoms before you cast your votes, check out our Fandom Wars master post! Ready? GO VOTE!

BBC Sherlock vs Harry Potter

supernatural vs doctor who

How much do you hate us right now? Whom are you voting for? Any interesting bets? Let us know in the comments below, and don’t forget to follow @ThreeChicGeeks on Twitter and like us on Facebook for the most current updates on the Fandom Deathmatch!

Hahaha, I almost did. It was difficult keeping a straight face when he asked me a question


Author: Katherine Erlikh

I love candlelight dinners, long walks on the beach and killing demons. Usually you can find me at rock concerts. 90% of redditors believe me to be male. I'm pretty sure I'm Loki.

79 thoughts on “The Fandom Wars: Round 4 (Semifinals)

  1. But… But… I can’t ! I cant’ choose!

  2. Don’t mind me, just dying of a broken heart here…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..*dies*

  3. Absolutely NOT!! No way can we decide between these guys 😛

  4. OUCH, my heart! ALL MY FANDOMS D:
    Oh, Harry Potter. My first fandom. I’m so, so sorry. But you just don’t have the glorious cheekbones and velvet baritone of Benedict Cumberbatch, or the hedgehog that is John Watson.
    This broke me. Sigh.

  5. I wish we could have a fandom war for once without the big Three and Harry Potter. No one else stands a chance, and it’s really boring.

  6. Harry Potter versus Sherlock? Are you- are you- are you freaking kidding me?!??!??!??!?!

  7. This was REALLY easy for me: Sherlock and Doctor Who. But I’m crumbling–I know what this means. You know what this means. Who will win the final round?? I CANNOT EVEN FATHOM THAT. The Ultimate Fandom. My, my–this is going to be extremely bloody.

  8. I’m physically in pain. Sherlock over my first love was painful, but Supernatural or Doctor Who…? Both. Both is the right answer. Not or.

  9. This is mean. These are 4 of my all time favorite fandoms!!!!! Harry Potter Vs Sherlock. Thats Cruel!!

  10. This was actually easier than the previous rounds. Harry Potter and Doctor Who have been my fandoms for years.

  11. What is this madness?!? How can I just toss away Harry Potter for the loveliness that is Benedict Cumberbatch?? I can’t. So I opted to not vote. It would be a horrible disservice to how equally awesome both are. Shame on you guys! My feels levels are so high 😦

  12. Oh the Humanity!!!!! Sherlock just cant go against Doctor Who. Its like asking to choose your favorite child… Its just not done….. Muahahaha, Let the carnage continue!!!!!

  13. I can’t. You can’t make me.

  14. I can’t believe what I just had to do, but Sherlock is just too damn good! I’m sorry Harry 😦

  15. Supernatural VS Doctor Who: This is way too cruel!! I’ll have to spend the night watching Doctor Who to make up for my betrayal!

  16. Pingback: The Fandom Chatroom | FanFiction Fridays

  17. Supernatural come on get those votes up!!! I love both shows but spr is currently my fav, mostly because Sam and dean are absurdly attractive. There should be a battle between the cutest characters!!!

  18. You. Are. Just. Cruel.


    Gah, Sherlock and Harry Potter which do I choose…….

  20. Harry Potter! Harry Potter must win or I WILL NOT BE OKAY! Just sayin’!

  21. THAT. WAS. MEAN.

  22. I hate everything.

    I went with my roots… Harry Potter was my first fandom (sorry BC – I still love you and your jaguar-cello voice!), and out of SuperWhoLock, Supernatural was my first. To the very end!

  23. I’m still pulling for Supernatural!

    *breaks down in tears anyway*

  24. You like making us suffer?


  26. Nooooooooo!!!! How can I possibly pick between Sherlock and Harry Potter?!?!?!

  27. Reblogged this on Cabinet of Curiosities and commented:
    OMG! How can you possibly pick between these! Go vote!

  28. Aaaaaaargh! I love all 4 of these, but HP has, and always will be, the greatest fandom in my mind. I honestly don’t have clear memories before I started reading HP, and I love the characters, the actors, Jo, the writing, the story, the lesson… Sherlock is amazing, but…

  29. I thought “Well, who is not in the HP fandom. I’m gonna vote Sherlock so they don’t lose by that much.” But no! No, no. Sherlock was already in the lead. How will this end… Bloody, is my prediction.

  30. I thought “Well, who is not in the HP fandom. I’m gonna vote Sherlock so they don’t lose by that much.” But no! No, no. Sherlock was already in the lead. How will this end… Bloody, is my prediction.

  31. This was a no contest for me. I have been and always will be a diehard Supernatural fan from day one. There IS NO contest to me. The boys got my vote, and I will never betray them or Harry (after all we watched him grow up)

  32. People are going to hate me for this but Im hoping that Sherlock wins against Harry Potter even though im a potter fan because i don’t want to have to choose between Harry Potter and Doctor Who

  33. Easy. Harry Potter & Doctor Who. But I hope one of them doesn’t go in the finals ‘cos it would be impossible to choose.

  34. GODNESS SAKE! Doctor who vs Supernatural? That hurts man!! I CAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAN’T!!!!

  35. B-but I loe sherlock and Doctor who! i cant choose if they win! QAQQAQ Nuuuu

  36. I can NOT choose between Supernatural and Doctor Who. How could you ask anybody to do such a thing?

  37. I can’t choose between Sherlock and Harry Potter….oh god. I’ll just cover my eyes and wait to see who wins…

  38. Was never really a fan of HP as much as everyone else. I can appreciate JK Rowling, and the movies, but I just wasn’t a fan of the books. Sherlock 100% for me (: (plus Benedict Cumberbatch – yum)


  40. So clear!

    1 Sherlock
    2 Doctor Who
    3 Harry Potter

    (SPN shouldn’t be on the list for me, it should have been Star Trek^^)

  41. HARRY POTTER the best!!

  42. Hp was my first fandom of the two, but I had to go with Sherlock… 😦

  43. HARRY POTTER AND DOCTOR WHO! NO CONTEST! Come on Potterheads, vote away!!!!

  44. Why did I have to choose between Sherlock and Harry Potter ? :(((( :thescreamface:

  45. I love Sherlock. I love, love, LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Sherlock. But after much deliberation, I knew that I had to pick Harry. Think about it. Harry Potter was THE. FIRST. FANDOM. We wouldn’t be having this horrible vote if Harry Potter hadn’t been written. It’s been around for far longer than this TV series, it was a beautiful work of art by a fantastic author, and it is still reaching out to audiences of all ages today. Sherlock does not reach young or very old audiences, it’s either too scary or too dramatic for them. Harry’s story resonates through the centuries, and anyone can connect with the magical story of the boy wizard. Not all of us will solve mysteries or become world famous detectives, but anyone can go through the changes Harry went through and imagine themselves in the magical world he lives in. In short, Harry was here first and left a legacy that Sherlock, although close hasn’t yet been able to follow up on. As Sherlock would say, “Heroes don’t exist, and if they did, I wouldn’t be one of them.” Harry Potter is a hero, and always will be.

    (So, Sherlock basically just told us to vote for Harry. I think that’s consolation enough).

    • I completely 100% agree with you! I LOOOOOOOVE Sherlock, but HP was the first. It is a story of love and friendship conquering evil, and it will always be first in my mind. Always.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s